Last hours to vote for the Best of Sonoma County finalists! Don't miss out!

Appeals court upholds Russian River frost-protection rules

  • Sprinklers coat a Santa Rosa vineyard with water as part of frost protection measures used due to early morning frost warnings in 2010. (PD FILE, 2010)

An appellate court has upheld state rules regulating how hundreds of farmers in Sonoma and Mendocino counties divert water from the Russian River to ward off frost.

The rules, aimed at protecting fish, were struck down in 2012 by Mendocino County Superior Court Judge Ann Moorman, who declared the law to be “constitutionally void” and “invalid.”

The state's First Appellate District court reversed her decision in a ruling filed Monday.

The State Water Resources Control Board lauded the decision.

“The board is pleased with the court's unanimous decision upholding the Russian River frost protection regulations,” Michael Lauffer, the board's chief counsel said in a statement.

Mendocino County Farm Bureau Manager Devon Jones said the appellate court ruling is a disappointment.

“We felt there was a very good opinion,” she said of the overturned ruling.

State regulators created the rules to prevent endangered and threatened salmon and steelhead trout from becoming stranded and dying when farmers pump water from the Russian River to ward off frost. Water is sprayed on vines to create a protective ice shield when temperatures fall below freezing.

The goal of the state rules is to avoid the sudden drops in river flows that can be caused when farmers throughout the river system pump water at the same time.

Several incidents in which rapid declines in river flows caused fish to become stranded triggered the regulations. Fisheries officials estimated some 25,000 salmonids were killed in two April 2008 episodes, one each in Sonoma and Mendocino counties. The incidents coincided with freezing temperatures, state officials said.

National Marine Fisheries Service officials blamed the strandings largely on farmers, especially grape growers. Grape plants are particularly susceptible to frost damage when new growth appears in the spring, the appellate court ruling noted. The Russian River watershed is home to more than 60,000 acres of vineyards. Of those, 70 percent are within 300 feet of salmonid habitat, the ruling said.

comments powered by Disqus
© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View