Sonoma County law enforcement officials promised a crowded community forum on Thursday that they will eventually answer the many questions surrounding the shooting death of Andy Lopez, but declined to discuss details of the case.
“I can assure you that once the decision is made, it will be a very public decision and my hope is that everybody understands the reason for my decision,” said District Attorney Jill Ravitch, who will determine whether sheriff's Deputy Erick Gelhaus acted properly when he shot the Santa Rosa teenager on Oct. 22.
“But until that time, there may be information you're not made aware of, and that's the nature of an investigation, so that the integrity can be protected,” she said.
Assistant Sheriff Lorenzo Dueñas refused to answer several pointed questions from audience members about why Gelhaus shot the youth seven times. He said the department is committed to examining its policies and procedures critically.
“What I can tell you is once the case is investigated and we look at it (through) an administrative review, we'll be able to answer some of those questions more thoroughly,” he said. “But right now I can't say that it was overkill or wasn't overkill. We have to look at all the facts.”
Santa Rosa Junior College hosted the forum in response to the shooting, which has generated protests, vigils, marches and meetings over the last three weeks.
Gelhaus shot Lopez after spotting him walking along Moorland Avenue in the middle of the afternoon carrying an airsoft BB gun that resembled an AK-47 rifle. Gelhaus told investigators that he believed the gun was real and was afraid the youth would shoot after he did not comply with a command to drop the gun and began turning toward the deputy.
Critics, however, have questioned whether Gelhaus gave Lopez sufficient time to understand who was yelling at him and comply with the order. Protesters in recent weeks have demanded that Ravitch file criminal charges against Gelhaus, but she has said that would be premature since the investigation is far from complete.